Skip to content
Study aid only. Verify against current guidelines before clinical use.

Free USMLE Step 2 CK Surgery practice questions

8 original exam-style questions from the StepStash 2,500-question Step 2 CK qbank, each with a full explanation, an educational objective and a link to the matching study note. Try each one before you open the answer. Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy.

Open the full 2,500-question Step 2 CK qbank

Question 1 · Toxic Shock Syndrome · easy

A 34-year-old man is brought to the emergency department 2 days after septoplasty because of fever, vomiting, watery diarrhea and dizziness that began this morning. Bilateral nasal packing was placed at the end of surgery, with removal planned at his postoperative visit tomorrow. Temperature is 39.6 C (103.3 F), pulse is 132/min, and blood pressure is 78/44 mm Hg. He is confused. Examination shows a diffuse blanching macular erythroderma over the trunk and extremities, bilateral conjunctival injection, and a hyperemic oropharynx. The packing is in place, and there is no purulent drainage. Laboratory studies show a platelet count of 82,000/mm3, serum creatinine of 2.4 mg/dL, and creatine kinase of 1,640 U/L. Blood cultures are drawn, intravenous crystalloid is infused, and intravenous vancomycin, piperacillin-tazobactam and clindamycin are started.

In addition to these measures, which of the following is the most appropriate intervention?

  1. Removal of the nasal packing
  2. CT scan of the paranasal sinuses before any procedure
  3. Intravenous immune globulin as the next priority
  4. High-dose intravenous methylprednisolone
  5. Exchange of the packing for antibiotic-impregnated packing
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Removal of the nasal packing

This man meets the clinical criteria for staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome: fever of at least 38.9 C, hypotension, diffuse macular erythroderma, and involvement of 3 or more organ systems (gastrointestinal, mucosal hyperemia, central nervous system, renal, hematologic and muscle). Nasal packing is a classic nonmenstrual source: S. aureus colonizing the retained foreign body produces the superantigen TSST-1, which nonspecifically activates a large fraction of T cells and triggers a cytokine storm with capillary leak. The local site often looks bland, and blood cultures are usually negative. As with a retained tampon, the single most important intervention after resuscitation is source control: remove the packing immediately, which stops ongoing toxin production at its origin. Aggressive fluids, norepinephrine for refractory hypotension, broad empiric antibiotics, and clindamycin (or linezolid) to inhibit toxin synthesis complete the core management.

B is wrong because imaging should not delay removal of an obvious foreign body source; CT is considered later only if a sinus or deep collection is suspected. C is wrong because IVIG may be considered as an adjunct in severe or refractory toxic shock, especially streptococcal TSS, but it never takes priority over source control. D is wrong because glucocorticoids have no proven benefit in TSS and are not part of standard therapy. E is wrong because any packing left in the nose, impregnated or not, remains a nidus for toxin-producing staphylococci; the packing must be removed, not replaced.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that toxic shock syndrome requires immediate removal of the source (tampon, nasal packing, infected wound) together with resuscitation, broad antibiotics and clindamycin to suppress toxin production.
Schematic comparing an ordinary peptide in the MHC class II groove, which activates only the few specific T cells, with TSST-1 clamping MHC class II to TCR V-beta outside the groove, which activates up to 20% of T cells, followed by the cytokine cascade (IL-1, IL-2, TNF-alpha, IFN-gamma) and the features of staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome.
Superantigens (TSST-1, SpeA/SpeC) skip the peptide groove and bridge MHC II to TCR Vβ, so up to 20% of T cells fire and the cytokine flood causes shock, although blood cultures are usually negative in staphylococcal TSS.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 2 · Shock · easy

A 24-year-old man is brought to the emergency department 30 minutes after being thrown from a motorcycle. He is awake and says he cannot feel or move his legs or hands. Pulse is 52/min, respirations are 20/min and shallow, and blood pressure is 78/42 mm Hg. Oxygen saturation is 97% on 2 L/min nasal cannula. His skin is warm, dry and pink below the clavicles, and capillary refill is brisk. There is no external bleeding. Breath sounds are equal bilaterally, the abdomen is soft, and the pelvis is stable. A focused assessment with sonography for trauma is negative, and chest and pelvic radiographs show no fractures or hemothorax. Rectal tone is absent.

Which of the following is the most likely cause of this patient's hypotension?

  1. Neurogenic shock
  2. Hemorrhagic shock
  3. Spinal shock
  4. Cardiac tamponade
  5. Tension pneumothorax
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Neurogenic shock

This patient has neurogenic shock from a cervical spinal cord injury. Weakness and loss of sensation in the hands and legs, absent rectal tone and shallow breathing point to a high cervical lesion. Injury above about T6 interrupts sympathetic outflow from the thoracolumbar cord, so arterial and venous tone fall and SVR drops. The cardiac accelerator fibers (T1 to T4) are also lost, leaving vagal tone unopposed. The result is the signature combination of hypotension with bradycardia and warm, dry, well-perfused skin, rather than the tachycardia and cold, clammy skin of hemorrhage.

Neurogenic shock remains a diagnosis of exclusion in trauma, because a cord injury does not protect against concurrent bleeding. Here the search is complete: no external hemorrhage, a negative FAST, a stable pelvis and clean chest and pelvic films. Treatment is fluids, then a vasopressor with alpha and beta activity such as norepinephrine to keep the MAP in the target range, and atropine or pacing for symptomatic bradycardia, while the spine is immobilized.

B. Hemorrhagic shock would produce tachycardia, a narrow pulse pressure and cool, vasoconstricted skin, and the evaluation found no source of bleeding. C. Spinal shock is the temporary loss of reflexes and flaccid paralysis below the level of injury; it explains the areflexia but is a neurologic, not a hemodynamic, term and does not itself mean hypotension. D. Cardiac tamponade causes obstructive shock with jugular venous distention, tachycardia and a pericardial effusion on FAST. E. Tension pneumothorax would cause unilateral absent breath sounds, tachycardia and distended neck veins, and the chest film is normal.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that hypotension with bradycardia and warm, dry skin after a cervical or high thoracic cord injury indicates neurogenic shock, once hemorrhage has been excluded.
Comparison of the two shocks after trauma: hemorrhagic shock (bleeding, hypovolemic) brings tachycardia and a narrowed pulse pressure before hypotension at about 30% blood volume loss, cold clammy skin, flat neck veins and a high SVR, and is treated with 1:1:1 blood products rather than large crystalloid volumes plus permissive hypotension until surgical control, while neurogenic shock (cord injury above T6, distributive) brings bradycardia from unopposed vagal tone, warm dry skin, flat neck veins and a low SVR and is treated with fluids, vasopressors and atropine; distended neck veins point instead to obstructive shock, and spinal shock is the temporary flaccid areflexia below a cord injury.
After trauma, a fast pulse with cold, clammy skin means hemorrhage (blood 1:1:1, permissive hypotension), while a slow pulse with warm, dry skin means neurogenic shock (fluids, vasopressors, atropine).

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 3 · Salivary gland tumors · medium

A 44-year-old woman comes to the office because of a painless lump in front of her left ear that she first noticed 2 years ago and that has grown slowly. She has no facial pain, numbness, or weakness. She does not smoke. Examination shows a 2.5-cm, firm, rubbery, nontender, mobile mass in the left parotid region. Facial nerve function is symmetric and intact in all branches. There is no cervical lymphadenopathy, and the oral cavity and oropharynx are normal. MRI shows a well-circumscribed, lobulated mass confined to the superficial lobe of the parotid gland. Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration shows a mixture of epithelial cells and myoepithelial cells in a chondromyxoid stroma, consistent with pleomorphic adenoma.

Which of the following is the most appropriate treatment?

  1. Enucleation of the mass through an intraoral incision
  2. Superficial parotidectomy with facial nerve preservation
  3. External beam radiation therapy
  4. Total parotidectomy with facial nerve sacrifice
  5. Observation with repeat MRI in 1 year
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: B. Superficial parotidectomy with facial nerve preservation

A slowly growing, painless, mobile parotid mass with intact facial nerve function in a middle-aged woman, with FNA showing epithelial and myoepithelial cells in chondromyxoid stroma, is a pleomorphic adenoma, the most common salivary gland tumor. It is benign, but it should be removed because it keeps growing and carries a small long-term risk of malignant transformation (carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma). The tumor has an incomplete capsule with fingerlike projections (pseudopodia) that extend beyond it, so simple shelling out leaves tumor behind and leads to multifocal recurrence. The standard operation for a tumor in the superficial lobe is superficial (or partial) parotidectomy with a cuff of normal tissue and identification and preservation of the facial nerve, which lies between the superficial and deep lobes.

A. Enucleation, by any approach, has a high recurrence rate because the capsular projections are left behind, and recurrent disease is multinodular and harder to cure. C. External beam radiation therapy is used as adjuvant treatment for salivary malignancies or recurrent disease, not as primary treatment of a benign, resectable tumor. D. Total parotidectomy with facial nerve sacrifice is reserved for malignant tumors that directly involve the nerve; sacrificing a functioning nerve for a benign tumor causes needless facial paralysis. E. Observation allows continued growth, makes later surgery more difficult, and accepts the risk of malignant change in a healthy young patient.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that a pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid is treated with superficial parotidectomy that preserves the facial nerve, because enucleation leaves capsular projections and leads to recurrence.
Lateral head schematic showing the parotid gland in front of the ear with the facial nerve (CN VII) branching through it, the submandibular gland under the jaw, the sublingual gland in the floor of the mouth and minor glands in the lips, colored from green to rose by how often their tumors are malignant; side panels give the malignant share by gland (parotid: 65 to 80% of all tumors, mostly benign; submandibular: larger share; minor glands: about half; sublingual: most), the red flags for malignancy, and why pleomorphic adenoma recurs after enucleation.
Most salivary tumors arise in the parotid and are benign; the smaller the gland, the likelier malignancy. Pain or CN VII palsy is a red flag, and pleomorphic adenoma recurs after enucleation because its projections breach the capsule.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 4 · Thymoma · medium

A 51-year-old man is referred to the thoracic surgery clinic after a CT scan obtained for a suspected kidney stone incidentally showed a mediastinal mass. He has no symptoms; specifically, he has no ptosis, double vision, dysphagia, fatigable weakness, dyspnea, or recurrent infections. Vital signs and physical examination are normal. Contrast-enhanced CT of the chest shows a 4 cm round, well-encapsulated, homogeneous soft-tissue mass in the anterior (prevascular) mediastinum with a clear fat plane separating it from the pericardium and great vessels; there is no pleural nodularity, effusion, or lymphadenopathy. Complete blood count, serum AFP, beta-hCG, and LDH are normal. Serum acetylcholine receptor antibodies are negative. Pulmonary function is normal.

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?

  1. CT-guided core needle biopsy of the mass
  2. Repeat CT of the chest in 6 months
  3. Definitive mediastinal radiation therapy
  4. Cisplatin-based neoadjuvant chemotherapy
  5. Total thymectomy with en bloc resection of the mass
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: E. Total thymectomy with en bloc resection of the mass

A well-encapsulated, homogeneous anterior mediastinal mass in a 51-year-old with normal germ cell tumor markers and no lymphadenopathy or B symptoms has the typical appearance of a thymoma. When imaging shows a resectable, encapsulated tumor, the standard of care is complete surgical resection: total thymectomy with en bloc removal of the mass (by sternotomy or a minimally invasive approach in experienced hands). Preoperative needle biopsy is avoided because breaching the capsule can seed the pleura or the needle tract, and a small core often cannot reliably distinguish thymoma subtypes anyway; the resected specimen provides the diagnosis and stage. Acetylcholine receptor antibodies were appropriately checked first so that occult myasthenia could be controlled before anesthesia, preventing a postoperative myasthenic crisis. Radiation is added afterward only for invasive or incompletely resected tumors.

A. Core needle biopsy is reserved for masses that appear unresectable or atypical (to plan induction therapy) or when lymphoma or germ cell tumor is suspected. B. Surveillance is not appropriate for a solid 4 cm thymic mass, because thymomas are malignant neoplasms with a potential for local invasion and pleural spread. C. Definitive radiation is used for patients who cannot undergo surgery or as adjuvant therapy, not as primary treatment of a resectable tumor. D. Neoadjuvant chemotherapy is considered for locally advanced, unresectable thymic tumors, not for a small encapsulated one.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that a resectable, encapsulated anterior mediastinal mass with the typical appearance of thymoma is removed by total thymectomy without preoperative needle biopsy, after AChR antibodies are checked.
Decision tree for an anterior mediastinal mass: orthopnea, stridor or tracheal narrowing on CT means biopsy under local anesthesia because general anesthesia can collapse the airway or circulation; otherwise the clue picks the lesion: age 40 to 60 with myasthenia, pure red cell aplasia or hypogammaglobulinemia means thymoma (AChR antibodies, then en bloc thymectomy without needle biopsy), a man aged 20 to 40 gets AFP, beta-hCG, LDH and scrotal ultrasound (any AFP rise means nonseminomatous germ cell tumor, normal AFP with normal or mildly raised beta-hCG and a homogeneous mass means seminoma, both treated with cisplatin-based chemotherapy), fat, fluid, calcification or teeth with normal markers means mature teratoma (excision), continuity with the cervical thyroid and a Pemberton sign mean retrosternal goiter (TSH, cervical thyroidectomy), and B symptoms in a young adult or adolescent mean lymphoma (tissue under local anesthesia, chemotherapy with or without radiation).
Check for airway compression first: a compressive mass is biopsied under local anesthesia. Thymoma is resected without needle biopsy after AChR antibodies, any AFP rise means a nonseminomatous germ cell tumor, and lymphoma needs core tissue (not FNA alone) and chemotherapy.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 5 · Human bite (fight bite) · medium

A 27-year-old man comes to the emergency department because of pain and swelling of his right hand for 2 days. He says he cut his hand on a door. On further questioning, he admits that he punched another man in the mouth 3 days ago. Temperature is 38.2 C (100.8 F). There is a 6-mm laceration over the dorsum of the right third metacarpophalangeal joint with surrounding erythema, warmth and purulent drainage. Flexion of the joint is painful and limited. X-ray of the hand shows no fracture or foreign body. The hand surgery service plans operative exploration and irrigation of the joint. He has no drug allergies.

Which of the following is the most appropriate empiric antibiotic therapy for this patient?

  1. Intravenous ampicillin-sulbactam
  2. Intravenous clindamycin
  3. Intravenous cefazolin
  4. Intravenous vancomycin
  5. Oral metronidazole
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Intravenous ampicillin-sulbactam

This is an infected clenched-fist injury (fight bite). When a fist strikes teeth, oral flora are driven through a small laceration into the metacarpophalangeal joint capsule and extensor tendon sheath; when the fingers extend, the tendon slides back and seals the inoculum inside. The result is septic arthritis, extensor tenosynovitis or osteomyelitis, often with a misleadingly small wound and a delayed, evasive history. Management is radiography, surgical exploration and irrigation, and antibiotics.

The organisms are mixed: Eikenella corrodens, viridans streptococci, Staphylococcus aureus and oral anaerobes (Prevotella, Fusobacterium). Intravenous ampicillin-sulbactam covers all of them, including beta-lactamase-producing anaerobes and staphylococci, and is the standard regimen for an established human-bite infection. Uninfected fight bites receive oral amoxicillin-clavulanate prophylaxis. If the patient has risk factors for MRSA, vancomycin can be added, but it is not a substitute for ampicillin-sulbactam.

B. Clindamycin covers staphylococci, streptococci and anaerobes, but Eikenella corrodens is intrinsically resistant to clindamycin, so clindamycin alone is a classic error after human bites. C. Cefazolin covers staphylococci and streptococci but has unreliable activity against Eikenella and oral anaerobes. D. Vancomycin alone covers gram-positive organisms, including MRSA, but misses Eikenella and gram-negative anaerobes. E. Metronidazole covers anaerobes only; Eikenella is resistant to it, and it does not treat staphylococci or streptococci.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that an infected fight bite requires surgical exploration plus IV ampicillin-sulbactam, because Eikenella corrodens is resistant to clindamycin and metronidazole.
Decision path for a bite wound: every bite is irrigated, debrided, explored, X-rayed if a fracture or retained tooth is possible and assessed for tetanus and rabies; a fight bite over an MCP joint goes to X-ray and hand-surgery exploration; only well-vascularized face or scalp wounds are closed; amoxicillin-clavulanate for 3 to 5 days goes to high-risk bites, sites and hosts, and penicillin allergy calls for doxycycline, TMP-SMX or a fluoroquinolone plus clindamycin or metronidazole.
Clean every bite first. A fight bite needs X-ray and hand-surgery exploration. Close only well-vascularized face or scalp wounds. Amoxicillin-clavulanate for 3 to 5 days covers cat and human bites, hand, foot, genital or near-joint wounds, deep punctures, crush injuries, sutured wounds and high-risk hosts; a superficial dog bite away from the hand in a healthy person needs wound care alone.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 6 · Hidradenitis suppurativa · medium

A 27-year-old woman comes to the office because of a recurrent painful, draining lump in her right axilla. Over the past 2 years, the same spot has been incised and drained four times in an urgent care center, each time healing for a few weeks and then recurring. Cultures were sterile twice and grew skin flora once. She also has occasional tender nodules in both groins that resolve on their own. She has a BMI of 33 kg/m2 and smokes 10 cigarettes daily. She completed a 12-week course of doxycycline 4 months ago, which reduced the groin nodules. Examination of the right axilla shows a 4-cm indurated cord with two openings that express malodorous serous discharge, surrounded by rope-like scars, with no fluctuance or cellulitis. Several double-ended comedones are present in both axillae. The left axilla and groins show scattered scars without tracts.

In addition to smoking cessation and weight loss counseling, which of the following is the most appropriate treatment for the right axillary lesion?

  1. Repeat incision and drainage
  2. Wide excision of the entire axillary skin with grafting
  3. Intralesional triamcinolone injection
  4. Deroofing of the sinus tract
  5. Laser hair removal of the axilla
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: D. Deroofing of the sinus tract

This woman has hidradenitis suppurativa (HS): recurrent painful nodules and abscesses in the axillae and groins, double-ended comedones, rope-like scars and sterile cultures, with obesity and smoking as risk factors. The right axilla now has an established sinus tract (tunnel) with two openings in a region of otherwise separated lesions, which is Hurley stage II disease.

HS begins with follicular occlusion and rupture, and the inflammation burrows into epithelialized tunnels. Incision and drainage opens only the acute collection and leaves the epithelialized tract behind, so the lesion recurs in the same spot, exactly what has happened four times here. The procedure of choice for a recurrent, localized tract is deroofing: under local anesthesia, a probe is passed through the tunnel, its roof is removed, the gelatinous base is curetted, and the wound heals by secondary intention with low recurrence and good cosmetic and functional results. Medical therapy (topical clindamycin, oral tetracyclines, or a biologic if refractory) continues alongside to limit new lesions, and smoking cessation and weight loss help control disease activity.

A. Repeat incision and drainage gives short-term relief of a fluctuant abscess, but this lesion is a chronic tract without fluctuance, and drainage would again leave the tunnel behind. B. Wide excision of the whole axilla with grafting or flap closure is reserved for diffuse, interconnected Hurley III disease; it is excessive for a single tract. C. Intralesional triamcinolone rapidly settles a single acutely inflamed nodule but does not remove an established epithelialized tunnel. E. Laser hair removal may reduce new follicular lesions in mild disease but does not treat an existing sinus tract.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that a recurrent hidradenitis suppurativa sinus tract (Hurley II) is treated with deroofing, because incision and drainage leaves the tract behind and the lesion recurs.
Four skin cross-sections show a follicle plugging, dilating, rupturing and inflaming, above three Hurley stage columns that pair drawings of isolated abscesses, a scarred tract and interconnected tunnels with their treatments, then lifestyle measures for every stage and the pitfall that incision and drainage leaves the tract.
HS begins as a plugged follicle that ruptures and inflames (TNF-α, IL-17), so cultures are often sterile. Treat by Hurley stage: topical clindamycin, then about 12 weeks of doxycycline or minocycline with deroofing, then adalimumab, secukinumab or bimekizumab with wide excision; I&D alone leaves the tract.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 7 · Postoperative Fever · hard

A 59-year-old man with type 2 diabetes underwent an elective open right hemicolectomy for adenocarcinoma 20 hours ago. Overnight he developed severe pain at the incision that is far out of proportion to his expected postoperative pain and is not controlled by his opioid infusion. Temperature is 39.4 C, pulse 128/min, and blood pressure 92/54 mm Hg. The skin around the incision is tense, dusky, and bronze, with edema extending beyond the visible erythema, and there is thin, gray, foul-smelling drainage; crepitus is palpated in the flank. The abdomen is otherwise soft. End-tidal CO2 was stable throughout the operation, and no succinylcholine or volatile agent was given. Leukocyte count is 24,000/mm3, serum sodium 129 mEq/L, and creatinine 1.8 mg/dL.

Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

  1. Atelectasis
  2. Superficial incisional surgical site infection
  3. Anastomotic leak
  4. Malignant hyperthermia
  5. Necrotizing soft tissue infection of the wound
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: E. Necrotizing soft tissue infection of the wound

The timing of postoperative fever usually narrows the cause, and fever within the first 24 hours is most often benign or related to the operation itself. A very early fever with pain out of proportion, systemic toxicity (tachycardia, hypotension), tense dusky or bronze skin, edema beyond the erythema, gray dishwater drainage, and crepitus, however, is a necrotizing soft tissue infection of the wound. Clostridium perfringens (gas gangrene, especially after bowel surgery) and group A Streptococcus cause rapidly progressive infections that can declare within hours of surgery; polymicrobial infections are also common, and diabetes is a major risk factor. Hyponatremia, leukocytosis above 15,000/mm3, and rising creatinine are typical laboratory clues. This is a surgical emergency: resuscitation, broad-spectrum antibiotics including clindamycin for toxin suppression, and emergent operative debridement, with repeat debridement as needed.

A is wrong because atelectasis does not cause wound findings, crepitus, or septic shock, and current evidence suggests it is not itself a cause of fever. B is wrong because an ordinary incisional infection presents around days 5 to 7 with erythema and purulent drainage, not within 24 hours with crepitus and shock. C is wrong because anastomotic leak typically declares on days 5 to 7 with peritonitis, and his abdomen is soft. D is wrong because malignant hyperthermia requires a volatile anesthetic or succinylcholine and presents intraoperatively or soon after with rising end-tidal CO2 and rigidity, not with wound necrosis.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that fever within 24 hours of surgery with severe wound pain, gray drainage, crepitus, and shock is a necrotizing wound infection (Clostridium or group A Streptococcus) that needs emergent debridement.
Timeline of postoperative complications by day from POD 0 to 8: malignant hyperthermia within hours and necrotizing wound infection very early, Wind (atelectasis, pneumonia) POD 1 to 2, perioperative MI POD 1 to 3, ileus expected up to 3 to 5 days, Water (UTI) POD 3 to 5, Walking (DVT or PE) POD 4 to 6, Wound (surgical site infection) and anastomotic leak POD 5 to 7, fascial dehiscence POD 5 to 8, and Wonder drugs or Weird (drug fever, abscess) from POD 7, each with its key test or action.
The day narrows the cause: hours means malignant hyperthermia, POD 1 to 2 atelectasis, 3 to 5 UTI, 4 to 6 DVT or PE, 5 to 7 wound infection or anastomotic leak, 5 to 8 dehiscence, and 7 or later drug fever or abscess. Perioperative MI (POD 1 to 3) is often silent, and ileus beyond 3 to 5 days needs a search for leak, abscess or obstruction.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Question 8 · Ankle sprain · hard

A 38-year-old woman comes to the emergency department 2 hours after rolling her left ankle inward when she missed a step at home. She felt immediate pain on the outside of the foot and ankle. She was able to walk to her car and into the department with a limp, taking more than 4 steps each time. She has no other injuries and takes no medications. Vital signs are normal. There is swelling and ecchymosis anterior and inferior to the lateral malleolus. Palpation of the posterior edge and tip of both malleoli over the distal 6 cm causes no bony tenderness, and there is soft-tissue tenderness over the anterior talofibular ligament. The navicular is nontender. Palpation of the base of the fifth metatarsal elicits sharp, localized pain. Distal pulses, capillary refill, and sensation are normal.

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in diagnosis?

  1. No imaging; rest, ice, compression, and elevation
  2. Radiographs of the ankle only
  3. Radiographs of the foot
  4. MRI of the ankle
  5. Ultrasonography of the lateral ankle ligaments
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. Radiographs of the foot

The Ottawa ankle and foot rules are highly sensitive decision rules that tell which acutely injured ankles and feet need radiographs. They have two parts. Ankle films are needed for bony tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of the distal 6 cm of either malleolus, or inability to bear weight for 4 steps both immediately and in the ED. Foot films are needed for bony tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular, or the same inability to bear weight. This patient walked more than 4 steps and has no malleolar bony tenderness, so the ankle portion is negative; her ATFL tenderness is ligamentous. However, she has point tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal, which is a positive foot rule. Inversion is the classic mechanism for an avulsion fracture of the fifth metatarsal base (pulled off by the peroneus brevis and lateral plantar aponeurosis) or a Jones fracture at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction, which has a high nonunion risk and different management. Foot radiographs (AP, lateral, and oblique) are therefore indicated.

A. Skipping imaging with RICE is correct only when every Ottawa criterion is negative; the fifth metatarsal tenderness makes this unsafe. B. Ankle films alone may not adequately show the fifth metatarsal base and are not indicated by her negative ankle examination. D. MRI is not a first-line study for acute ankle trauma; it is reserved for persistent symptoms suggesting osteochondral, syndesmotic, or occult injuries after initial radiographs. E. Ultrasound can show ligament tears, but ligament status does not change the initial treatment of a lateral sprain and it does not replace radiographs to exclude fracture.

Educational objective: The key takeaway is that under the Ottawa rules, bony tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular calls for foot radiographs even when the ankle portion of the rule is negative.
Outer and inner views of the ankle and foot mark the Ottawa palpation points: the posterior edge of the distal 6 cm and the tip of each malleolus for ankle films, and the base of the 5th metatarsal and the navicular for foot films; criteria cards add inability to bear weight for 4 steps both immediately and in the ED, a green box says all negative means no X-ray with RICE and early mobilization, and sprain notes say inversion tears the ATFL most often, then the calcaneofibular ligament, while external rotation causes a high ankle sprain.
Press the posterior edge (distal 6 cm) and tip of each malleolus for ankle films and the navicular and 5th metatarsal base for foot films; inability to bear weight for 4 steps both immediately and in the ED also calls for films. All negative: no X-ray, RICE and early mobilization.

Read the study note on this topic

Reviewed by Veli Bakalov, MD · @HemeOncBuddy

Build a timed block from the full 2,500-question Step 2 CK qbank

Free USMLE Step 2 CK practice questions · Free Step 1 questions