Abuse, Neglect & Family Violence
Recognize inflicted injury and know exactly when reporting is mandatory
The reporting framework
Suspicion, not proof. Physicians are mandated reporters of child abuse and neglect and of elder or dependent-adult abuse. The threshold is reasonable suspicion: report to Child Protective Services (CPS) or Adult Protective Services (APS) without waiting for proof, confronting the family, or gaining consent. Reporters acting in good faith are legally immune, and failure to report is a crime.
| Situation | Report? | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Child abuse or neglect | Mandatory | Report to CPS on suspicion; ensure the child's safety |
| Elder or vulnerable-adult abuse | Mandatory | Report to APS on suspicion |
| Factitious disorder imposed on another | Mandatory | Report as child abuse |
| Gunshot, stab, or other violent injuries | Often mandatory | Follow state law, even for competent adults |
| IPV against a competent adult | Not mandated in most states | Keep it confidential; support, safety-plan, refer |
| Adult sexual assault | The patient's choice | Offer care and forensic exam; the patient decides about police |
Child physical abuse: recognizing inflicted injury
Developmental stage is everything. Always ask whether the history is plausible for the child's mobility. In a non-ambulatory infant (not yet cruising or walking), any long-bone fracture and any bruise is suspicious: "those who don't cruise rarely bruise." A spiral fracture from twisting is worrisome in an infant, whereas a spiral tibia ("toddler's fracture") and shin bruises are usually accidental in a walking child. Other red flags are a delay in seeking care, a changing or vague story, and a mechanism that does not match the injury.
Fractures. The most specific for abuse are posterior rib fractures, from squeezing the chest, which levers the ribs against the spine. CPR and short falls do not cause them. Classic metaphyseal lesions (corner or bucket-handle fractures) come from shaking or yanking a limb. Scapular, sternal, and spinous-process fractures are also highly specific, and multiple fractures at different stages of healing suggest repeated trauma.
| Injury | Usually accidental | Suggests abuse |
|---|---|---|
| Fractures | Toddler's spiral tibia, clavicle, distal radius buckle in a mobile child | Posterior ribs, metaphyseal corner fractures, scapula, sternum, spinous processes; any long-bone fracture in a pre-walker |
| Burns | Splash or spill: irregular margins, satellite drops, variable depth | Immersion: sharp waterline, symmetric stocking or glove pattern, spared flexion creases and buttocks ("donut"); round ~8 mm deep cigarette burns |
| Bruises | Bony prominences (shins, forehead) in a walker | TEN-4 regions or any bruise in a young infant; patterned bruises (hand, loop, belt) |
Abusive head trauma (shaken baby). The triad is multilayered retinal hemorrhages extending to the periphery, subdural hematoma from torn bridging veins, and diffuse axonal injury. There are often no external signs. The infant presents with lethargy, irritability, vomiting, poor feeding, seizures, or apnea, which are easily mistaken for a viral illness. Severe retinal hemorrhages rarely follow accidental short falls.
Workup of suspected abuse, and neglect
- Skeletal surveyIn every child under age 2 with suspected physical abuse; repeat in about 2 weeks to catch healing fractures that were occult at first.
- Dilated fundoscopyBy ophthalmology, for retinal hemorrhages.
- NeuroimagingNon-contrast head CT (MRI to follow) if abusive head trauma is suspected.
- CBC and coagulation studiesTo exclude a bleeding disorder that mimics bruising.
- Report and protectReport to CPS; evaluate siblings and other children in the home.
Mimics to exclude include osteogenesis imperfecta (blue sclerae, family history), bleeding disorders such as hemophilia and vitamin K deficiency, congenital dermal melanocytosis (slate-gray "Mongolian spots"), and cultural practices such as coining and cupping.
Neglect. Neglect is the most common form of child maltreatment: failure to provide food, shelter, supervision, medical or dental care, or education. Clues are failure to thrive, poor hygiene, severe dental caries, missed immunizations and appointments, and developmental delay. It is reportable just like physical abuse.
Elder abuse and intimate partner violence
Elder abuse. Forms include physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, financial exploitation, neglect, and abandonment. The key risk factors are cognitive impairment or dementia, functional dependence, social isolation, and caregiver stress or substance use. Most abusers are family members. Clues include unexplained bruises, poor hygiene, missed medications, and a caregiver who controls the patient's money. Report suspected cases to APS.
- Tension buildingThe victim is "walking on eggshells."
- Acute batteringAn explosive violent incident.
- HoneymoonContrition and promises to change.
- Cycle repeatsOften escalating over time.
IPV screening. Screen women of reproductive age (USPSTF grade B), interviewing the patient alone, with a professional interpreter if needed, never the partner or a family member. Pregnancy can trigger or escalate violence. Suspect IPV with injuries inconsistent with the story, a delay in presentation, repeated visits, or a partner who will not leave the room.
Management in a competent adult. In most states, do not report to police. Respect autonomy while you validate the disclosure, document injuries (the patient's own words, body diagrams), assess immediate safety, build a safety plan, and offer resources such as the National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-SAFE).
Do not pressure the patient to leave: homicide risk peaks at separation. Injuries from firearms or knives are separately reportable in many states, even in competent adults.
Sexual assault and factitious disorder imposed on another
Sexual assault care. Ensure safety and treat injuries, then offer a forensic exam by a Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) with an intact chain of custody. The patient decides whether to involve police: a forensic exam does not require a police report, and evidence can be collected up to about 120 hours (5 days) after the assault. Offer:
- Emergency contraception (after a pregnancy test); it works better the sooner it is given
- Empiric STI prophylaxis: ceftriaxone plus doxycycline plus metronidazole
- HIV post-exposure prophylaxis, which must start within 72 hours
- Hepatitis B vaccination, plus counseling and follow-up testing
Factitious disorder imposed on another (Munchausen by proxy). A caregiver, usually a parent, fabricates or induces illness in a child to assume the sick role by proxy; there is no external reward such as money. Clues are recurrent unexplained illness, symptoms that appear only when the caregiver is present and resolve on separation, and an overly attentive, medically savvy parent who pushes for more tests. Example: hypoglycemia with high insulin and low C-peptide points to injected exogenous insulin. This is child abuse and must be reported.